Community

Roth posted an interesting article concerning Germanic tribes and how laws were dispensed. One of points described the shared will of the community.

Important decisions were made collectively. At assemblies, free men and women—practices varied by tribe and era—gathered to deliberate on matters of war and peace, alliances, disputes, and the well-being of the community. There, they spoke, listened to one another, and strove to reach a decision. It was not the power of a single individual that was to determine the fate of all, but the shared will of the community.

Underlying this concept was a profound mythological idea: the human being was not an isolated entity, but a thread in the great tapestry of the kin group. Every action affected the fate of all. Honor, therefore, was not merely personal renown but the standing of the entire lineage. Those who acted justly strengthened the community. Those who committed treason, murder, robbery, or perjury did not merely harm individuals; they disrupted the order that bound ancestors, the living, and future generations together.

For this reason, a chieftain alone did not adjudicate serious transgressions. The community deliberated on what form of restitution or punishment corresponded to the wrong that had been committed. Depending on the deed, this might entail compensation, penance, banishment, or—in the case of particularly grave crimes—even death. The goal was not mere retribution, but the restoration of peace within the community. Order had to be renewed so that the trust binding the kin-group could endure.

From my personal experience, survival groups have failed in the past mainly due to the inexperience of the “leadership” and immorality of its members.

I came to the conclusion that building community is a better strategy. My first premise was that you can build community easier with a community center. Taking your life’s savings to buy land and build the foundation for a community center is not a light commitment but it was one that the Lord led me to make.

I foolishly thought that if I built it, the people would come. And they came for my head. Since I kept to myself, I did not know many people in my area. It did not take long for the “racist” accusation to be made and propagated to marginalize my efforts. As Dalton told me: that was bad ju ju.

This was in 2017 which was the fruition of Obama’s program to destroy our culture through division using government funding of NGOs. There are very few black Americans in Cherokee County and I learned a valuable lesson: people will use any lie to divide or marginalize people and their efforts.

Were my efforts and sacrifices made in vain? You may as well ask if the Lord was leading me astray. I came to the conclusion that the timing was not right and continued building a foundation for the community when the collapse happened.

So what is the point? A community center without moral people and leaders will fail. Infrastructure is only the beginning.

Justice, security and property rights are the keys to building a successful community. Our government’s descent into evil has brought chaos, a two-tiered justice system, unsecured borders and bankruptcy. I look at the government’s failures as a blueprint for a community’s success: if you do not let evil into your community and you have moral leadership, you will grow and prosper.

5 1 vote
Article Rating

7 responses to “Community”

  1. Yes, you see the problem. As one of the founding father’s admonished us, it is a nation for a just and honest Christian people. We cannot survive as our nation once was (cuz, admit it, it no longer is at this point), without a return to a moral and principled people.
    A large part of this nation DOES NOT want to return to a country that is like that. They like the changes that have taken place, and want to go further! Obviously the two sides are incompatible. What we are left with is intractable division where each side tries to out-vote and punish the other for ‘crimes’ committed during the previous reign of power. Thus ensuring a continual cycle of reprisal, while the real criminals continue to loot the treasury. Truth tellers will be disparaged, you’ve experienced it, David. ‘People’ just want free $hit and someone agreeing with what they already think.
    There’s been a bit of noticing lately, too, so we’re going to kill a whole bunch of the males with a completely un-related distraction in Persia. Anywhere on the other side of the planet will-do, really.
    BUT, if you just protest more, and voat moar harderer, our side might just make it…
    (Lucy yanks the ball away again)
    Whocoulddaknowd!
    Balkanization is the best hope, stronger states, weaker federalism, but that’s in direct conflict with the beast we’re fighting (‘d33p stayte’). It really is 1776 or bust (err.. 1860, but win this time).

  2. And allowing women to be in positions of power and vote on issues they clearly have no knowledge in except their emotional feelings are why we are were we are at….

  3. That’s a big reason why the dissident side fails time and time again is that no one knows them so they are easily vilified any they try and start something….

  4. As I may have mentioned before, I, too, have been part of several ‘groups;’ prepper, survival, patriot, and intentional (read same culture, race, faith). All failed for the reasons David described above. I agree with him. It’s the timing. I don’t think building a true ‘community’ will work until there is a lot, repeat – A LOT, of pain experienced by the normies. That’s coming, I think, sooner than later.

    Leadership, too. One who puts the community first, but would need to be very disciplined and, dare I say, harsh in maintaining the rules and order. Warlord is too strong a description, but something not too far removed. Strength and honor.

    I’m quite certain David is prepared in his AO to pick up the baton when the time comes just as I am here. When the time comes …

    We all need to be ready.

  5. If you cannot find enough people of honor and good neighbor quality to form an unofficial Mutal Assistance Group in good times…

    How are you going to build a trustworthy team of honorable Warriors for their Honorable Disciplined Warlord when the lights go out?

    Every one of my friends, I’ve known for many years and most I’ve served with in the Sandbox. We’ve helped some move here and build homes here over the decades.

    People I can trust with my house keys and taking care of my animals while I was unavailable for over a month.

    Our area study has noted a couple of wannabe warlords and we’ve already figured out the best ways to eliminate them as they are a Hazard to any homesteader defending their family groups.

    As I don’t want to break OPSEC and lose David’s respect I’ll leave it at that. I’ll be fighting evil when the lights go out and die defending mine.

  6. David –

    You make an excellent observation that infrastructure alone is not a sufficient pre-condition to stimulate the development of a culture with a shared morality.

    Let’s examine your criteria for community’s success: “if you do not let evil into your community and you have moral leadership, you will grow and prosper”

    This is a good start, but requires two enhancements: (1) an accurate and agreed definition of evil, and (2) an ability to establish a boundary within which absolute control can be exercised by the community.

    To be aligned with Roths’ “The Judgment of the Kin”, the agreed definition of evil must be “malum in se” and the community agree to redress only acts that cause harm to an individual.

    To be aligned with Roth’s “Anarchy – The Forgotten Primal Source of Freedom” the community must be free from “malum prohibitum” and any external agency with the power to coerce beyond the redress of evil.

    Implementation of these two enhancements are problematic. The Sin nature of fallen man drives men to establish coercive power structures for governance and control. The delicate balance of homogeneity necessary for a culture of moral people will be constantly disrupted by travel and migration; geographic “Balkanization” will always be insufficient.

    I conclude the best we will accomplish is the establishment of virtual communities with a feudal relationship to a larger coercive “state”, where we pay tribute to be left largely alone.

    My ancestors were Germanic and I find much of what Roth writes about the “old ways” comfortable. However, as with the English and American common law, the councils and the courts worked because they were artifacts of an already moral people.

    My journey from atheism to Faith very late in life brought me to Christ, to aspire to live according to God’s will, and to express gratitude for the Law, the Gospel and Grace.

    “Man’s chief end is to glorify God and to enjoy Him forever.” This perspective suggests human existence has significance and that God intends for man to have a destiny both in the present world and in the afterlife.

    Morality first … then, by extension, the chief end of humanity is to manage communal life on Earth peacefully, justly, and moderately.

    ————————
    Hans … in the NC woods … just passing through this world

  7. “Morality first … then, by extension, the chief end of humanity is to manage communal life on Earth peacefully, justly, and moderately.”

    Hans … you just nailed it with this line!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

7
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x